fix: use passive QQ event replies

This commit is contained in:
zenord
2026-08-18 22:20:55 +08:00
parent 4af5049605
commit ffedf616e3
9 changed files with 560 additions and 48 deletions
+208 -8
View File
@@ -68,6 +68,9 @@ const policy = { allowedUsers: [] as string[], allowedChats: [] as string[], req
const message = (text: string, messageId = text, chatId = "chat"): IncomingMessage => ({
platform: "qq", chatId, userId: "user", text, messageId
});
const groupMessage = (text: string, messageId: string): IncomingMessage => ({
platform: "qq", chatId: "group:g1", userId: "user", text, messageId, isGroup: true
});
const flush = async () => { await Promise.resolve(); await Promise.resolve(); await new Promise<void>((resolve) => setImmediate(resolve)); };
const waitFor = async (condition: () => boolean) => {
for (let count = 0; count < 50 && !condition(); count++) await flush();
@@ -78,6 +81,25 @@ function recordingAdapter(sent: OutgoingMessage[] = []): PlatformAdapter {
return { name: "test", async handleWebhook() { return {}; }, async sendMessage(outgoing) { sent.push(outgoing); } };
}
// Simulates QQ passive-reply dedup: a repeated msg_id + msg_seq pair is rejected.
function qqDedupAdapter(sent: OutgoingMessage[] = [], fail?: (outgoing: OutgoingMessage) => string | undefined): PlatformAdapter {
const used = new Set<string>();
return {
name: "test",
async handleWebhook() { return {}; },
async sendMessage(outgoing) {
const failure = fail?.(outgoing);
if (failure) throw new Error(failure);
if (outgoing.replyTo) {
const pair = `${outgoing.replyTo}|${outgoing.replySequence}`;
if (used.has(pair)) throw new Error("QQ send failed: HTTP 400 code=400304018 duplicate msg_id+msg_seq");
used.add(pair);
}
sent.push(outgoing);
}
};
}
function createGateway(runtime = new FakeRuntime()) {
return { runtime, gateway: new Gateway(policy, runtime) };
}
@@ -159,7 +181,7 @@ test("runtime errors remain runtime errors and are delivered through the same st
assert.deepEqual(sent.map((outgoing) => [outgoing.text, outgoing.replySequence]), [["Agent error: failed", 1]]);
});
test("sendEvent pushes a fresh message to the latest chat target without replyTo", async () => {
test("sendEvent uses a fresh passive window with replyTo and an incrementing sequence", async () => {
const { runtime, gateway } = createGateway();
const sent: OutgoingMessage[] = [];
const turn = gateway.receive(message("work", "event-source"), recordingAdapter(sent));
@@ -168,11 +190,14 @@ test("sendEvent pushes a fresh message to the latest chat target without replyTo
await turn;
await gateway.sendEvent("qq:chat", "任务完成了");
const event = sent.at(-1)!;
assert.equal(event.text, "任务完成了");
assert.equal(event.replyTo, undefined);
assert.equal(event.replySequence, undefined);
assert.deepEqual(event.target, { platform: "qq", chatId: "chat", userId: "user", raw: undefined });
await gateway.sendEvent("qq:chat", "又完成了一步");
// The normal reply already consumed msg_seq 1 for "event-source"; events share the same counter.
const events = sent.filter((outgoing) => outgoing.text !== "done");
assert.deepEqual(events.map((outgoing) => [outgoing.text, outgoing.replyTo, outgoing.replySequence]), [
["任务完成了", "event-source", 2],
["又完成了一步", "event-source", 3]
]);
assert.deepEqual(events[0]!.target, { platform: "qq", chatId: "chat", userId: "user", raw: undefined });
});
test("sendEvent uses the most recent target and adapter for the chat", async () => {
@@ -190,7 +215,8 @@ test("sendEvent uses the most recent target and adapter for the chat", async ()
await gateway.sendEvent("qq:chat", "event");
assert.equal(firstSent.filter((outgoing) => outgoing.text === "event").length, 0);
assert.equal(secondSent.at(-1)?.text, "event");
assert.equal(secondSent.at(-1)?.replyTo, undefined);
assert.equal(secondSent.at(-1)?.replyTo, "two");
assert.equal(secondSent.at(-1)?.replySequence, 2); // "two done" consumed seq 1 for message "two"
});
test("sendEvent drops safely when the chat has no known target", async () => {
@@ -198,13 +224,187 @@ test("sendEvent drops safely when the chat has no known target", async () => {
await gateway.sendEvent("qq:unknown", "event");
});
test("expired group passive window skips the event and reminds on the next inbound", async () => {
let now = 1_000_000;
const runtime = new FakeRuntime();
const gateway = new Gateway(policy, runtime, { now: () => now });
const sent: OutgoingMessage[] = [];
const adapter = recordingAdapter(sent);
const turn = gateway.receive(groupMessage("work", "m1"), adapter);
await waitFor(() => runtime.turns.length === 1);
runtime.turns[0].resolve("done");
await turn;
now += 4 * 60_000; // within the 4.5 minute group window
await gateway.sendEvent("qq:group:g1", "fresh event");
assert.deepEqual(sent.at(-1), {
target: { platform: "qq", chatId: "group:g1", userId: "user", raw: undefined },
text: "fresh event", replyTo: "m1", replySequence: 2 // "done" consumed seq 1 for m1
});
now += 2 * 60_000; // past the group window
await gateway.sendEvent("qq:group:g1", "stale event");
assert.equal(sent.filter((outgoing) => outgoing.text === "stale event").length, 0);
const status = await gateway.receive(groupMessage("/status", "m2"), adapter, { synchronous: true });
assert.match(status.reply || "", /lastEventDelivery=skipped/);
assert.match(status.reply || "", /lastEventError=no fresh passive window/);
assert.match(status.reply || "", /lastEventAt=\d{4}-\d{2}-\d{2}T\d{2}:\d{2}:\d{2}/);
const reminder = gateway.receive(groupMessage("hello", "m3"), adapter);
await waitFor(() => runtime.turns.length === 2);
runtime.turns[1].resolve("ok");
await reminder;
const reminded = sent.find((outgoing) => outgoing.text === "stale event");
assert.equal(reminded?.replyTo, "m3");
assert.equal(reminded?.replySequence, 1);
// The stale event was already flushed once; a later inbound must not repeat it.
const again = gateway.receive(groupMessage("hello again", "m4"), adapter);
await waitFor(() => runtime.turns.length === 3);
runtime.turns[2].resolve("ok");
await again;
assert.equal(sent.filter((outgoing) => outgoing.text === "stale event").length, 1);
});
test("status reports the last successful event delivery for the current chat", async () => {
const { runtime, gateway } = createGateway();
const adapter = recordingAdapter();
const turn = gateway.receive(message("work", "m1"), adapter);
await waitFor(() => runtime.turns.length === 1);
runtime.turns[0].resolve("done");
await turn;
await gateway.sendEvent("qq:chat", "event");
const status = await gateway.receive(message("/status", "m2"), adapter, { synchronous: true });
assert.match(status.reply || "", /lastEventDelivery=success/);
assert.match(status.reply || "", /lastEventError=none/);
assert.match(status.reply || "", /lastEventAt=\d{4}-\d{2}-\d{2}T/);
});
test("normal replies and fresh events share one msg_seq counter per inbound message", async () => {
const runtime = new FakeRuntime();
const gateway = new Gateway(policy, runtime);
const sent: OutgoingMessage[] = [];
const turn = gateway.receive(groupMessage("work", "m1"), qqDedupAdapter(sent));
await waitFor(() => runtime.turns.length === 1);
runtime.turns[0].resolve("done");
await turn;
// With independent counters these events would reuse (m1, seq 1) and QQ would reject them.
await gateway.sendEvent("qq:group:g1", "event one");
await gateway.sendEvent("qq:group:g1", "event two");
assert.deepEqual(sent.map((outgoing) => [outgoing.text, outgoing.replyTo, outgoing.replySequence]), [
["done", "m1", 1],
["event one", "m1", 2],
["event two", "m1", 3]
]);
});
test("a redelivered inbound message id continues its msg_seq counter instead of restarting", async () => {
const runtime = new FakeRuntime();
const gateway = new Gateway(policy, runtime);
const sent: OutgoingMessage[] = [];
const adapter = qqDedupAdapter(sent);
const first = gateway.receive(groupMessage("work", "m1"), adapter);
await waitFor(() => runtime.turns.length === 1);
runtime.turns[0].resolve("first done");
await first;
// QQ pushed the same msg_id again: the reply must not reuse (m1, seq 1).
const second = gateway.receive(groupMessage("work", "m1"), adapter);
await waitFor(() => runtime.turns.length === 2);
runtime.turns[1].resolve("second done");
await second;
assert.deepEqual(sent.map((outgoing) => [outgoing.text, outgoing.replyTo, outgoing.replySequence]), [
["first done", "m1", 1],
["second done", "m1", 2]
]);
});
test("flushed pending events and the current reply share the msg_seq counter", async () => {
let now = 1_000_000;
const runtime = new FakeRuntime();
const gateway = new Gateway(policy, runtime, { now: () => now });
const sent: OutgoingMessage[] = [];
const adapter = qqDedupAdapter(sent);
const first = gateway.receive(groupMessage("work", "m1"), adapter);
await waitFor(() => runtime.turns.length === 1);
runtime.turns[0].resolve("done");
await first;
now += 6 * 60_000; // past the group window: the event is queued instead of sent
await gateway.sendEvent("qq:group:g1", "stale event");
assert.equal(sent.filter((outgoing) => outgoing.text === "stale event").length, 0);
const second = gateway.receive(groupMessage("hello", "m2"), adapter);
await waitFor(() => runtime.turns.length === 2);
runtime.turns[1].resolve("ok");
await second;
// The redelivery takes (m2, seq 1) and the current turn's reply takes (m2, seq 2); no pair collides.
assert.deepEqual(sent.map((outgoing) => [outgoing.text, outgoing.replyTo, outgoing.replySequence]), [
["done", "m1", 1],
["stale event", "m2", 1],
["ok", "m2", 2]
]);
});
test("failed pending event redelivery stays queued, records failed, and retries on the next inbound", async () => {
let now = 1_000_000;
const runtime = new FakeRuntime();
const gateway = new Gateway(policy, runtime, { now: () => now });
const sent: OutgoingMessage[] = [];
let failEvent = true;
const adapter = qqDedupAdapter(sent, (outgoing) => failEvent && outgoing.text === "stale event"
? "QQ send failed: HTTP 400 code=40034105 proactive message not allowed"
: undefined);
const first = gateway.receive(groupMessage("work", "m1"), adapter);
await waitFor(() => runtime.turns.length === 1);
runtime.turns[0].resolve("done");
await first;
now += 6 * 60_000;
await gateway.sendEvent("qq:group:g1", "stale event"); // skipped, queued
const second = gateway.receive(groupMessage("hello", "m2"), adapter);
await waitFor(() => runtime.turns.length === 2);
runtime.turns[1].resolve("ok");
await second;
// The redelivery failed: nothing was delivered, but the normal reply still went out.
assert.equal(sent.filter((outgoing) => outgoing.text === "stale event").length, 0);
assert.deepEqual(sent.map((outgoing) => [outgoing.text, outgoing.replyTo, outgoing.replySequence]), [
["done", "m1", 1],
["ok", "m2", 2]
]);
const status = await gateway.receive(groupMessage("/status", "ms"), adapter, { synchronous: true });
assert.match(status.reply || "", /lastEventDelivery=failed/);
assert.match(status.reply || "", /lastEventError=HTTP 400 QQ code 40034105/);
failEvent = false;
const third = gateway.receive(groupMessage("hello again", "m3"), adapter);
await waitFor(() => runtime.turns.length === 3);
runtime.turns[2].resolve("ok again");
await third;
const redelivered = sent.filter((outgoing) => outgoing.text === "stale event");
assert.equal(redelivered.length, 1);
assert.equal(redelivered[0]!.replyTo, "m3");
assert.equal(redelivered[0]!.replySequence, 1);
});
test("sendEvent delivery failures are logged safely without message content", async () => {
const { runtime, gateway } = createGateway();
const errors: string[] = [];
const adapter: PlatformAdapter = {
name: "test", async handleWebhook() { return {}; },
async sendMessage(outgoing) {
if (!outgoing.replyTo) throw new Error("sensitive provider response");
if (outgoing.text.includes("event text")) throw new Error("sensitive provider response");
}
};
const turn = gateway.receive(message("work", "event-failure"), adapter);